{
  "role": "visualization_reviewer",
  "decision": "pass",
  "summary": "The model-authored figure_ref and table_ref choices are accurate, and all visible numbers in the article, table, and figure caption match the supplied analysis results. The shared publication assets carry minor unit-labeling limitations that are recorded as notes under the replay review contract.",
  "findings": [
    {
      "severity": "note",
      "check": "figure_ref accuracy",
      "evidence": "The article's figure_ref block targets 'wind-offense-by-bin', which exists in publication_assets.figures with a defined alt text and caption. The alt text and caption correctly name the population (1,323 outdoor/open NFL games, 2018-2025), the two outcomes, the units (play share; EPA per dropback), the estimator (game-level means with 95% bootstrap intervals), and the sparse 20+ mph bin (n=31), matching analysis.sample.",
      "recommendation": "None; the reference is accurate."
    },
    {
      "severity": "note",
      "check": "table_ref accuracy",
      "evidence": "The table_ref block targets 'wind-primary-effects'. All four rows match analysis.primary_effects exactly: dropback 54.0% vs 52.1% (-1.8 pts, -3.4 to -0.4), completion 60.3% vs 58.0% (-2.3 pts, -3.4 to -1.1), EPA per dropback 0.056 vs -0.011 (-0.067, -0.104 to -0.031), combined points 46.1 vs 42.3 (-3.8, -6.2 to -1.3). The table caption correctly states the comparison frame (15+ mph vs below 10 mph) and that differences are unadjusted with bootstrap intervals.",
      "recommendation": "None; the reference and values are accurate."
    },
    {
      "severity": "note",
      "check": "shared figure axis units",
      "evidence": "In the immutable chart code (_write_chart), neither panel carries a y-axis unit label; the dropback panel relies on a percent tick formatter and the EPA panel has no unit annotation on the chart itself. Units are defined only in the caption/alt text, so a screenshot without the caption would leave the EPA panel's units implicit. Per the replay review contract, this is a shared-asset limitation recorded as a note, not a variant defect.",
      "recommendation": "For future shared-asset revisions, add explicit y-axis unit labels (e.g., 'Share of neutral early-down plays' and 'EPA per dropback') to both panels."
    },
    {
      "severity": "note",
      "check": "shared figure per-bin sample sizes",
      "evidence": "The chart displays four wind bins but does not annotate per-bin game counts on the plot; only the 20+ mph bin's sparsity (n=31) is disclosed in the caption. The 15-19 mph bin (153 games at 15+ mph) is the analysis's primary threshold and is visible, so no central figure is missing. Shared-asset limitation recorded as a note.",
      "recommendation": "For future shared-asset revisions, annotate per-bin n on the chart so a standalone screenshot conveys the unbalanced sample sizes."
    },
    {
      "severity": "note",
      "check": "title contract",
      "evidence": "The figure suptitle ('NFL offense by reported game wind, 2018-2025') names the population and time frame, and panel titles name the outcomes; the comparison frame (bin means) is defined in the caption. The article title names population, outcome, magnitude, and years. This satisfies the screenshot-context contract when the caption travels with the figure.",
      "recommendation": "None."
    },
    {
      "severity": "note",
      "check": "visual emphasis vs analysis",
      "evidence": "The figure shows unadjusted bin means with 95% bootstrap intervals and does not overstate the analysis: the article text and callout explicitly frame results as retrospective associations, not causal or forecast claims, and the 20+ mph underpowering and 2022-2023 coverage limitation are disclosed. No deceptive scales or mismatched values were found.",
      "recommendation": "None."
    }
  ],
  "artifacts_reviewed": [
    "wind-offense-by-bin (figure_ref and shared SVG/PNG asset)",
    "wind-primary-effects (table_ref and shared table asset)",
    "article text and article_markdown numeric claims against analysis.primary_effects and analysis.adjusted_per_5_mph"
  ],
  "model": "z-ai/glm-5.3",
  "created_at": "2026-09-03T04:31:14.436000+00:00"
}