{
  "annotation_type": "post-run engineering note",
  "actions_run": "https://github.com/MaxRogers5/fourth-down-labs/actions/runs/33346526146",
  "artifact_integrity": "Original run files are preserved unmodified. This note was added after the rejected run and is not included in its manifest hash inventory.",
  "original_status": "rejected",
  "publication_disposition": "The candidate article was not published and no publication pull request was opened.",
  "what_worked": [
    "The code-locked registration matched the executed analysis.",
    "The current 2025 source, dual provenance records, artifact inventory, and row-count reconciliation were visible to every role.",
    "All five review artifacts recorded transport-authoritative role, z-ai/glm-5.3 model identity, and timestamp.",
    "The researcher and citation checker produced detailed, traceable pass decisions."
  ],
  "why_it_failed": [
    "The statistician issued a revise decision for concrete article framing changes around bootstrap interpretation, selection effects, and individual-level application.",
    "The adversarial reviewer returned a pass decision containing a literal placeholder blocking finding.",
    "The editor returned literal placeholder summary and finding text.",
    "The JSON schema enforced structure but did not yet enforce minimum semantic content or decision/finding coherence."
  ],
  "remediation": [
    "Require minimum lengths for review summaries and finding fields.",
    "Reject a pass decision containing a blocking finding and a block decision without one.",
    "Retry invalid structured outputs rather than writing placeholder artifacts.",
    "Remove the bootstrap win-rate framing and explain that resamples are not independent replications.",
    "Bound the tiebreaker advice to a population-level heuristic and disclose the uncertain direction of survivor conditioning.",
    "Trace the email subject to a generated statistic and cite both nflverse source files."
  ]
}