{
  "artifacts": {
    "analysis.json": "0add3f647d9e7585ac9fdb4c3be8ed1f78f280e17ed2d1361873a410ce6d0eeb",
    "article.md": "70d008c295ce701e0037e0554ca8b87d96c4c0f3517b27d4982229b474086570",
    "claim-ledger.json": "525af7a737889997307ceefea9b98580bb7984107882ba6ba483b1fa1a267a94",
    "data/drafted-wr-outcomes.csv": "5b25c5829e3a9a66a9e1b1cd22b840663aedabe4bf9adac70e42fffa28a672a9",
    "data/first-three-seasons.csv": "daff2943f20625ff6cf53fc3983cadcaf538da3a8c1a2417ab041652234b5590",
    "data/hit-rates-by-round.csv": "d838dfc50a38501b448d51de5149ac0dd179430e1046b914838d9c36d3de31cf",
    "data/hit-rates-by-tier.csv": "3048ec01850762bf1eae2ac97ff430b3fc3078283fca8b511d0d73e175a3492b",
    "figure-specs.json": "28a44abe488340b896b7bce8f6f4756506f9a192878306ba0004abd858369510",
    "figures/rookie-wr-hit-rate-by-round.png": "9e74e7d506e5a821c26d7fe374b2844356229395b8e0d441f33c04921ee41212",
    "figures/rookie-wr-threshold-ladder.png": "32ad1cd2e89e18e00a2ba814555fbe50a5a12ccf57c35875911919e9eaee3a5e",
    "openrouter-call-ledger.json": "3cfb2fea58c05f349b1441ede0de7fbdd15a05a4e43bb4c2b2a49b0c2c230a20",
    "provenance.json": "6b70c28955418ffc975fbdf4f56683e2734aa6567f612a53b005c5e234a878ce",
    "publication-decision.json": "d337edec6fffc59e2096c15e3a74c3d766feda253e1cfde51f5c45412f98d801",
    "research-memo.json": "2556bf58925ad4be3f560401ef52b9afc1a90697d7db0489f92041f852a5e60c",
    "review-adversarial_reviewer.json": "d26b4c00c391716fe6d36f71d44d2fd51c2e3bdf431884f3478dde61ac025d28",
    "review-citation_checker.json": "6d6314721f680a432cceeb7bc74c360ce17c920e0755284fb6a0cf5408b6554e",
    "review-code_methods_reviewer.json": "4d8d23f25d6749005be91eb7754c2f28631271f92aa2cfce229d516a4c30e2d8",
    "review-cycles/cycle-1/review-adversarial_reviewer.json": "d26b4c00c391716fe6d36f71d44d2fd51c2e3bdf431884f3478dde61ac025d28",
    "review-cycles/cycle-1/review-citation_checker.json": "6d6314721f680a432cceeb7bc74c360ce17c920e0755284fb6a0cf5408b6554e",
    "review-cycles/cycle-1/review-code_methods_reviewer.json": "4d8d23f25d6749005be91eb7754c2f28631271f92aa2cfce229d516a4c30e2d8",
    "review-cycles/cycle-1/review-editor.json": "8ef547b22c891ca3c6795add260dda5ba46f3f1ec14f2d2f5f520652835fc51f",
    "review-cycles/cycle-1/review-researcher.json": "8c4c94bca35f28f6b01cac9ade3ffb3e24b696d28ec10abb06b5985320fa0080",
    "review-cycles/cycle-1/review-statistician.json": "ab536fc6b73e64c8232f381a2d06ec2dc1bbbaa39d61972412daf107c7a3a626",
    "review-cycles/cycle-1/review-visualization_reviewer.json": "d37d3ad4181c4e791f9740213b0cd44a13c878853dac754ccc6a003a434c3c13",
    "review-editor.json": "8ef547b22c891ca3c6795add260dda5ba46f3f1ec14f2d2f5f520652835fc51f",
    "review-researcher.json": "8c4c94bca35f28f6b01cac9ade3ffb3e24b696d28ec10abb06b5985320fa0080",
    "review-statistician.json": "ab536fc6b73e64c8232f381a2d06ec2dc1bbbaa39d61972412daf107c7a3a626",
    "review-visualization_reviewer.json": "d37d3ad4181c4e791f9740213b0cd44a13c878853dac754ccc6a003a434c3c13"
  },
  "code_version": "0.3.0",
  "completed_at": "2026-08-31T23:11:22.591962+00:00",
  "data": [
    {
      "attribution": "Draft data made available by nflverse contributors from PFR records.",
      "bytes": 1656280,
      "license": "CC BY 4.0 (nflverse compilation; underlying NFL data retain owner terms)",
      "notes": [
        "The release includes additional draft years; analysis uses only cohorts with a complete three-season outcome window.",
        "Players without a weekly stat record remain in the denominator."
      ],
      "retrieved_at": "2026-08-31T23:10:25.472022+00:00",
      "seasons": [
        2010,
        2011,
        2012,
        2013,
        2014,
        2015,
        2016,
        2017,
        2018,
        2019,
        2020,
        2021,
        2022,
        2023
      ],
      "sha256": "91f1ead0d531aec7e219e3f19756b3084d8ef6d8dbf37c8b4ec147dd3985c215",
      "source_name": "nflverse draft picks",
      "source_url": "https://github.com/nflverse/nflverse-data/releases/download/draft_picks/draft_picks.csv",
      "source_version": "draft_picks release asset retrieved 2026-08-30"
    },
    {
      "attribution": "Weekly player statistics made available by nflverse contributors.",
      "bytes": 33447747,
      "license": "CC BY 4.0 (nflverse compilation; underlying NFL data retain owner terms)",
      "notes": [
        "Regular-season PPR totals are summed from weekly rows.",
        "NFL data accessed through nflverse belong to their respective owners."
      ],
      "retrieved_at": "2026-08-31T23:10:25.474125+00:00",
      "seasons": [
        2010,
        2011,
        2012,
        2013,
        2014,
        2015,
        2016,
        2017,
        2018,
        2019,
        2020,
        2021,
        2022,
        2023,
        2024
      ],
      "sha256": "45b06f7b7c88cf8338b239653eeb8063c0d4e4cd814de6f13d55e9ab88101de7",
      "source_name": "nflverse player stats",
      "source_url": "https://github.com/nflverse/nflverse-data/releases/download/player_stats/player_stats.csv",
      "source_version": "player_stats asset updated 2025-05-07; seasons through 2024"
    },
    {
      "attribution": "Player statistics made available by nflverse contributors.",
      "bytes": 882104,
      "license": "CC BY 4.0 (nflverse compilation; underlying NFL data retain owner terms)",
      "notes": [
        "The per-season release supplies the latest fully completed season.",
        "NFL data accessed through nflverse belong to their respective owners."
      ],
      "retrieved_at": "2026-08-31T23:10:25.499379+00:00",
      "seasons": [
        2025
      ],
      "sha256": "aaa8559478dd8d58569c93e278239e70e9411e79ee649c99d8d506030cd42b12",
      "source_name": "nflverse 2025 regular-season player statistics",
      "source_url": "https://github.com/nflverse/nflverse-data/releases/download/stats_player/stats_player_reg_2025.csv",
      "source_version": "nflverse 2025 player_stats release asset"
    }
  ],
  "deterministic_seed": 8032,
  "openrouter_models": {
    "adversarial_reviewer": "z-ai/glm-5.3",
    "citation_checker": "z-ai/glm-5.3",
    "code_methods_reviewer": "z-ai/glm-5.3",
    "editor": "z-ai/glm-5.3",
    "researcher": "z-ai/glm-5.3",
    "statistician": "z-ai/glm-5.3",
    "visualization_reviewer": "z-ai/glm-5.3"
  },
  "publication_decision": "publication-decision.json",
  "reviews": [
    "review-researcher.json",
    "review-statistician.json",
    "review-code_methods_reviewer.json",
    "review-adversarial_reviewer.json",
    "review-citation_checker.json",
    "review-visualization_reviewer.json",
    "review-editor.json"
  ],
  "run_id": "2026-08-31T231023Z-rookie-wr-hit-rates-gh33449432433",
  "series_id": "rookie-wr-hit-rates",
  "started_at": "2026-08-31T23:10:24.213146+00:00",
  "status": "published"
}