{
  "role": "visualization_reviewer",
  "decision": "pass",
  "summary": "The figure and table contracts are internally consistent with the reported effects: all group means, adjusted differences, 95% intervals, and Holm p-values in the table and article text match the analysis JSON (52.3%/54.0%, -1.6 pts, -3.1 to -0.1, 0.097; 7.32/7.32, +0.04 yds, -0.17 to +0.25, 1.000; 58.2%/60.0%, -1.5 pts, -2.6 to -0.5, 0.015; 2.0%/2.1%, ~0, -0.3 to +0.2, 1.000). The figure caption names the contrast (observed rain minus explicitly rain-free), the estimand (adjusted game-level differences with 95% HC3 robust intervals), the population/time frame (NFL games through 2024), and that each panel keeps its native unit, so a screenshot reader can interpret it without article context. The table caption correctly distinguishes unadjusted group means from adjusted differences. Uncertainty is displayed beside every estimate, and the article does not visually overstate the suggestive dropback result (Holm p = 0.097 is explicitly flagged as not clearing the threshold).",
  "findings": [
    {
      "severity": "note",
      "check": "accessibility_text_defines_units_and_contrast",
      "evidence": "publication_assets.figures[0].alt",
      "recommendation": "The alt text ('Effect panels compare passing and play-calling outcomes...') names population, contrast, and time frame but not the units or that bars are 95% intervals. The caption supplies these, so this is a bounded accessibility note, not a blocker; consider enriching the alt text with per-panel units and interval meaning for screen-reader users."
    },
    {
      "severity": "note",
      "check": "denominators_visible_in_figure_context",
      "evidence": "publication_assets.figures[0]",
      "recommendation": "The figure caption does not state the sample sizes (181 rain vs 1,056 rain-free of 1,237 comparable games). The article text and table context carry this, but a standalone screenshot of the figure alone would omit the denominators; adding them to the caption would strengthen the standalone contract."
    },
    {
      "severity": "note",
      "check": "unit_consistency",
      "evidence": "analysis.effects[3].units",
      "recommendation": "Turnover rate is stored in turnovers-per-play but rendered as '2.0% of plays' / '-0.0 pts'; the conversion is arithmetically consistent (0.0204 vs 0.0207) and the table labels it as a percentage, so no mismatch, but the figure's 'native unit' phrasing should ensure the turnover panel is labeled as percent-of-plays rather than raw per-play rate."
    }
  ],
  "artifacts_reviewed": [
    "weather-rain-playcalling-effects",
    "weather-rain-playcalling-table"
  ],
  "model": "z-ai/glm-5.3",
  "created_at": "2026-09-03T08:42:35.316890+00:00"
}