{
  "run_id": "2026-09-06T164926Z-wr-target-share-stability-gh34046620715",
  "series_id": "wr-target-share-stability",
  "status": "published",
  "started_at": "2026-09-06T16:49:27.638581+00:00",
  "completed_at": "2026-09-06T16:49:27.757367+00:00",
  "deterministic_seed": 4444,
  "code_version": "generated-research-desk-final-review-resume-v1",
  "data": [
    {
      "source_name": "nflverse 2018 weekly player statistics",
      "source_url": "https://github.com/nflverse/nflverse-data/releases/download/stats_player/stats_player_week_2018.csv",
      "source_version": "nflverse 2018 player_stats release asset",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-09-06T05:52:33.238260+00:00",
      "license": "CC BY 4.0",
      "attribution": "Data made available by nflverse contributors.",
      "sha256": "c53021bcfc9f89d30edd6f1fe145a1d7d6ce469efeec75974fe9f0adac568642",
      "bytes": 7792665,
      "seasons": [
        2018
      ],
      "notes": [
        "Downloaded fresh for this run; the run manifest records its SHA-256.",
        "Underlying NFL data remain subject to their owners' terms."
      ]
    },
    {
      "source_name": "nflverse 2019 weekly player statistics",
      "source_url": "https://github.com/nflverse/nflverse-data/releases/download/stats_player/stats_player_week_2019.csv",
      "source_version": "nflverse 2019 player_stats release asset",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-09-06T05:52:33.507391+00:00",
      "license": "CC BY 4.0",
      "attribution": "Data made available by nflverse contributors.",
      "sha256": "a05558126b1209b80fe11a8f18938cb35816370bf9990975a87de49e9eed7376",
      "bytes": 7767165,
      "seasons": [
        2019
      ],
      "notes": [
        "Downloaded fresh for this run; the run manifest records its SHA-256.",
        "Underlying NFL data remain subject to their owners' terms."
      ]
    },
    {
      "source_name": "nflverse 2020 weekly player statistics",
      "source_url": "https://github.com/nflverse/nflverse-data/releases/download/stats_player/stats_player_week_2020.csv",
      "source_version": "nflverse 2020 player_stats release asset",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-09-06T05:52:33.687121+00:00",
      "license": "CC BY 4.0",
      "attribution": "Data made available by nflverse contributors.",
      "sha256": "05b992676faccc8940efbf6242cb76358069372d31d7c2e02c1a4acdcd3cbe18",
      "bytes": 7883270,
      "seasons": [
        2020
      ],
      "notes": [
        "Downloaded fresh for this run; the run manifest records its SHA-256.",
        "Underlying NFL data remain subject to their owners' terms."
      ]
    },
    {
      "source_name": "nflverse 2021 weekly player statistics",
      "source_url": "https://github.com/nflverse/nflverse-data/releases/download/stats_player/stats_player_week_2021.csv",
      "source_version": "nflverse 2021 player_stats release asset",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-09-06T05:52:33.900624+00:00",
      "license": "CC BY 4.0",
      "attribution": "Data made available by nflverse contributors.",
      "sha256": "41915fb49238902ad1f129ebf0405b11a1e710454ae0fe8f7b3e4f9145875f48",
      "bytes": 8477784,
      "seasons": [
        2021
      ],
      "notes": [
        "Downloaded fresh for this run; the run manifest records its SHA-256.",
        "Underlying NFL data remain subject to their owners' terms."
      ]
    },
    {
      "source_name": "nflverse 2022 weekly player statistics",
      "source_url": "https://github.com/nflverse/nflverse-data/releases/download/stats_player/stats_player_week_2022.csv",
      "source_version": "nflverse 2022 player_stats release asset",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-09-06T05:52:34.120406+00:00",
      "license": "CC BY 4.0",
      "attribution": "Data made available by nflverse contributors.",
      "sha256": "ad426c3fe5bf1cc30c3f137fdfe96d054e19d400879ee4413129da49fa7b54be",
      "bytes": 8408729,
      "seasons": [
        2022
      ],
      "notes": [
        "Downloaded fresh for this run; the run manifest records its SHA-256.",
        "Underlying NFL data remain subject to their owners' terms."
      ]
    },
    {
      "source_name": "nflverse 2023 weekly player statistics",
      "source_url": "https://github.com/nflverse/nflverse-data/releases/download/stats_player/stats_player_week_2023.csv",
      "source_version": "nflverse 2023 player_stats release asset",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-09-06T05:52:34.318242+00:00",
      "license": "CC BY 4.0",
      "attribution": "Data made available by nflverse contributors.",
      "sha256": "f19cb71a5de0dce7fd09376026237c9ee9d5a93fe13815a2ea3ec2d37204cb17",
      "bytes": 8332874,
      "seasons": [
        2023
      ],
      "notes": [
        "Downloaded fresh for this run; the run manifest records its SHA-256.",
        "Underlying NFL data remain subject to their owners' terms."
      ]
    },
    {
      "source_name": "nflverse 2024 weekly player statistics",
      "source_url": "https://github.com/nflverse/nflverse-data/releases/download/stats_player/stats_player_week_2024.csv",
      "source_version": "nflverse 2024 player_stats release asset",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-09-06T05:52:34.517587+00:00",
      "license": "CC BY 4.0",
      "attribution": "Data made available by nflverse contributors.",
      "sha256": "3ddc45a84f759aa348ce465ae001752c530575455717657cdfe1f8abfcdb4759",
      "bytes": 8470040,
      "seasons": [
        2024
      ],
      "notes": [
        "Downloaded fresh for this run; the run manifest records its SHA-256.",
        "Underlying NFL data remain subject to their owners' terms."
      ]
    },
    {
      "source_name": "nflverse 2025 weekly player statistics",
      "source_url": "https://github.com/nflverse/nflverse-data/releases/download/stats_player/stats_player_week_2025.csv",
      "source_version": "nflverse 2025 player_stats release asset",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-09-06T05:52:34.697202+00:00",
      "license": "CC BY 4.0",
      "attribution": "Data made available by nflverse contributors.",
      "sha256": "e5e0615b3d96a3eaebfaee91e55afb4a4e7fe0caf057454177bcd7d6ad4bcfc2",
      "bytes": 8656387,
      "seasons": [
        2025
      ],
      "notes": [
        "Downloaded fresh for this run; the run manifest records its SHA-256.",
        "Underlying NFL data remain subject to their owners' terms."
      ]
    },
    {
      "source_name": "nflverse NFL schedules",
      "source_url": "https://github.com/nflverse/nflverse-data/releases/download/schedules/games.csv",
      "source_version": "nflverse schedules release asset",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-09-06T05:52:34.857440+00:00",
      "license": "CC BY 4.0",
      "attribution": "Data made available by nflverse contributors.",
      "sha256": "c9d3896dafb1ca89b0bd9196d7e5948b16d56cb258a145bd71ef771069c3a605",
      "bytes": 2177170,
      "seasons": [
        1999,
        2000,
        2001,
        2002,
        2003,
        2004,
        2005,
        2006,
        2007,
        2008,
        2009,
        2010,
        2011,
        2012,
        2013,
        2014,
        2015,
        2016,
        2017,
        2018,
        2019,
        2020,
        2021,
        2022,
        2023,
        2024,
        2025,
        2026
      ],
      "notes": [
        "Downloaded fresh for this run; the run manifest records its SHA-256.",
        "Underlying NFL data remain subject to their owners' terms."
      ]
    }
  ],
  "artifacts": {
    "analysis.json": "ca2a0589bcde8d77da18e9b2ebd7a0f410932a94e58483851ed0d92cf723dce9",
    "article-candidate.json": "152f629cfa9189575d1fe43d8c955baae8394e1d2fafaa65070b20e6f59327a7",
    "article-draft.json": "2aef9838abe1d4e82a560d64f497024bb6beb87199be6ccc7043469e4484794b",
    "article.md": "2426198961cf57982a7f3c9425a93876eb22c82fba20a9c1a7cf859ae1a649aa",
    "claim-ledger-attempt-1.json": "e9e4f175667f127ddccc7735af8a9e2568f640221d460df46a8209e3dd94482c",
    "claim-ledger.json": "e9e4f175667f127ddccc7735af8a9e2568f640221d460df46a8209e3dd94482c",
    "determinism-run-1/analysis.json": "ca2a0589bcde8d77da18e9b2ebd7a0f410932a94e58483851ed0d92cf723dce9",
    "determinism-run-1/figures/wr-target-share-error-curve-figure.png": "16b2fa3eef769ac28af6b9b01cbaed4ef9b726d60c4ff991228b2ec1f283c2f6",
    "determinism-run-1/publication-assets.json": "73a531c7f704e3aa548b9e9fc5a19978bedf7d73dd0553b0168055d5ffaa784c",
    "determinism-run-1/tables/wr-target-share-main-results-table.csv": "95ed9337eff809722509b3110f3451795744b8497ae3ad3a1e9aa12b79dee104",
    "determinism-run-2/analysis.json": "ca2a0589bcde8d77da18e9b2ebd7a0f410932a94e58483851ed0d92cf723dce9",
    "determinism-run-2/figures/wr-target-share-error-curve-figure.png": "16b2fa3eef769ac28af6b9b01cbaed4ef9b726d60c4ff991228b2ec1f283c2f6",
    "determinism-run-2/publication-assets.json": "73a531c7f704e3aa548b9e9fc5a19978bedf7d73dd0553b0168055d5ffaa784c",
    "determinism-run-2/tables/wr-target-share-main-results-table.csv": "95ed9337eff809722509b3110f3451795744b8497ae3ad3a1e9aa12b79dee104",
    "deterministic-numeric-facts.json": "f5320afdd296d198c3cfe9d7a1b04a1bdcacf4bc59ce501e812ce67ac3155d68",
    "editorial-copy-repair.json": "2c11d2c28ab7a7155c454fe1257f2247910afdec77a6e85d0a17e5afdce050d8",
    "figures/wr-target-share-error-curve-figure.png": "16b2fa3eef769ac28af6b9b01cbaed4ef9b726d60c4ff991228b2ec1f283c2f6",
    "generated/analysis.py": "5aae89df51f996d2f6aa15bc2cae35d610f1d083bee27ed89e42cbc95b157e0f",
    "generated/test_analysis.py": "0bef849fadb35f12b6ab6903f4e82a6abdf61096b93ef0c03b5ee3459743ec35",
    "generated-package-cache-candidate.json": "543dbf02deb1f0a468712a9245e426bfe49283a81f1489fcf352e433fcc13233",
    "generated-package.json": "dcbcb4785b49fc2bf053901403f65936b1509c653f1cdd5f04cdd452bf3dcd37",
    "generation-status.json": "5c3ee2584931b81908c3fd118301766c9f4cc699821a4dd510a8fc054dae9b15",
    "implementation-repair-attempt-1.json": "dcbcb4785b49fc2bf053901403f65936b1509c653f1cdd5f04cdd452bf3dcd37",
    "implementation-repair-package.json": "dcbcb4785b49fc2bf053901403f65936b1509c653f1cdd5f04cdd452bf3dcd37",
    "implementation-review/cycle-1/code_methods_reviewer.json": "05ada48672f7a2b3a546480aa2d999387d661d4ed696451e39f20e1b0ae8fe0b",
    "implementation-review/cycle-1/statistician.json": "04a72be30f581c28bba712de526f667cbca5fc3939c2b91bfd871314bdc0d258",
    "implementation-review/cycle-2/code_methods_reviewer.json": "81d665470ef4d5882e800979b3eeed1536ff985c193e81be3b4be49db6ca2b78",
    "implementation-review/cycle-2/statistician.json": "fc059931acfa7d1223774334df0eac7896010b4cda224e9f2cfb2320214b5611",
    "implementation-source-edits-1.json": "b6330ddfda78e0483cc12492d9e633f4ce96b31bb95d61c578668279e53c3a64",
    "openrouter-call-ledger.json": "58a0a5d12e9e3faddecd7b4aa735054ba3e5824ab55dd1f99cc73a84f8d43275",
    "provenance.json": "4c56b8d6df57d003fc0a0eaea1719eb3c8822fba812209a87b8a8d7b24f1b1a3",
    "publication-assets.json": "73a531c7f704e3aa548b9e9fc5a19978bedf7d73dd0553b0168055d5ffaa784c",
    "publication-decision.json": "cdad1d9a6053134a0e16ca1dd3357cb242b8ef6aec2c00dff9ebb0dedb693f5f",
    "registered-distribution-amendment.json": "7bcfa245549a3b6c02bdc82f3a524f2b119dd046f965761967c26d07680bdaa6",
    "research-proposal.json": "72044109261370cf62fc8325e8367f30567542a4395979337a6e6a6ac09249f3",
    "research-registration-status.json": "5560cde4ae4fda50c03468450f115679da40d938ea1ab141b917e77d4628de86",
    "research-registration.json": "c17d0215c31ebb758d4eec3b5237ec700341f7925ef012a0d727a88ecef3cbe2",
    "resume-checkpoint.json": "93d15e6dd17c79227cb8582b7062f5fee19739c3b3b28709d4f0230a47e315b1",
    "review-adversarial_reviewer.json": "db36086402b01a55f7250c03960400a07a32fe8d2bc2857ac73e662072b4a792",
    "review-citation_checker.json": "8531620b0d50c58c8baf3a6ab2eb97cb263d6e3f8b106aa1e892f7f2ddd17707",
    "review-code_methods_reviewer.json": "b0ff90f520078f0338c883dc554af2186713eb8cc38afabf50dbc92b7bd0bbdd",
    "review-cycles/cycle-1/review-adversarial_reviewer.json": "e1cadef20e9e52f407067fc69e4a30436a8e00eebc53291748d702d2774cc25e",
    "review-cycles/cycle-1/review-citation_checker.json": "26afa0da8188a9d81b7b44e88556091fc0d828afa19f3389f26654574d642967",
    "review-cycles/cycle-1/review-code_methods_reviewer.json": "62126fa4b2a728f8a8cb7d5046c518382df7c37fab8de2b35bf0b065f6f3ecf1",
    "review-cycles/cycle-1/review-editor.json": "5b1693de858a44ab7bb82a377b9a063e876f9c780461415c701450352def35cf",
    "review-cycles/cycle-1/review-researcher.json": "5609ad8f43c90229f473b0103b02456f0c7fe22baf459cb1e3436d15f9b25aad",
    "review-cycles/cycle-1/review-statistician.json": "86decc6ba7f897dac9fadc56020c807eb928a7f4eb533ec2a6bd09b67146f443",
    "review-cycles/cycle-1/review-visualization_reviewer.json": "7cffd8434c4769118d60d341f11aa0eb922bdad62718746123b254e725220169",
    "review-cycles/cycle-2/review-adversarial_reviewer.json": "309e59050a35e4705139b9f11a2e2f77c6ea5f3eb64bc497ccaf19ed246875c5",
    "review-cycles/cycle-2/review-citation_checker.json": "3b5ff4fb532d41a9a7543bb70ff222bd40eded4e1959c15b8d5c778a6da45ba3",
    "review-cycles/cycle-2/review-code_methods_reviewer.json": "dd71811aaee0b55322583126b22a503e148181a9f829e30025765f7686fa6038",
    "review-cycles/cycle-2/review-editor.json": "0f1aed82cb1b8b2b22be1725516d4359eeb327c6715ce83dc87cdb89f125c8fe",
    "review-cycles/cycle-2/review-researcher.json": "e87189a317e26492fb9c42b0032321f46e943ebc4c3b726346d6b6f3bf78268c",
    "review-cycles/cycle-2/review-statistician.json": "0e53a1e36f897006e4a32cb6b24f457954dd9caa64f3d5d456ca885f4c2ff95c",
    "review-cycles/cycle-2/review-visualization_reviewer.json": "69fd73f4e128e40293075d6486b8d5036dff2fd4f78e8facb005157e4d652fdc",
    "review-cycles/cycle-3/review-adversarial_reviewer.json": "db36086402b01a55f7250c03960400a07a32fe8d2bc2857ac73e662072b4a792",
    "review-cycles/cycle-3/review-citation_checker.json": "8531620b0d50c58c8baf3a6ab2eb97cb263d6e3f8b106aa1e892f7f2ddd17707",
    "review-cycles/cycle-3/review-code_methods_reviewer.json": "b0ff90f520078f0338c883dc554af2186713eb8cc38afabf50dbc92b7bd0bbdd",
    "review-cycles/cycle-3/review-editor.json": "ed034d2c1beeaca0b52a7f13bccc5d6880add98e0c80884fb8a7782cfc8ae423",
    "review-cycles/cycle-3/review-researcher.json": "92505367c2f6a72ce8abb6ae322b9e6f12f4b4e3ab9c9dcedac32f692332f7c2",
    "review-cycles/cycle-3/review-statistician.json": "9d39ea9537441ff94f77cc5b47d0ee1195ccf20afc3f094d4b34f7a40db782b7",
    "review-cycles/cycle-3/review-visualization_reviewer.json": "a82e45525fc1ce62b03d5f6b47a2e6323bc648168409652b4b2309285cb5e251",
    "review-editor.json": "ed034d2c1beeaca0b52a7f13bccc5d6880add98e0c80884fb8a7782cfc8ae423",
    "review-researcher.json": "92505367c2f6a72ce8abb6ae322b9e6f12f4b4e3ab9c9dcedac32f692332f7c2",
    "review-statistician.json": "9d39ea9537441ff94f77cc5b47d0ee1195ccf20afc3f094d4b34f7a40db782b7",
    "review-visualization_reviewer.json": "a82e45525fc1ce62b03d5f6b47a2e6323bc648168409652b4b2309285cb5e251",
    "search-demand-brief.json": "efaf8341809d8ffc584c36b02006f38cad8bacbfc1e62308adb6655aefe84ba1",
    "tables/wr-target-share-main-results-table.csv": "95ed9337eff809722509b3110f3451795744b8497ae3ad3a1e9aa12b79dee104"
  },
  "reviews": [
    "review-researcher.json",
    "review-statistician.json",
    "review-code_methods_reviewer.json",
    "review-adversarial_reviewer.json",
    "review-citation_checker.json",
    "review-visualization_reviewer.json",
    "review-editor.json"
  ],
  "publication_decision": "publication-decision.json",
  "openrouter_models": {
    "adversarial_reviewer": "openai/gpt-5.6-sol",
    "citation_checker": "openai/gpt-5.6-sol",
    "code_methods_reviewer": "openai/gpt-5.6-sol",
    "editor": "openai/gpt-5.6-sol",
    "researcher": "openai/gpt-5.6-sol",
    "statistician": "openai/gpt-5.6-sol",
    "visualization_reviewer": "openai/gpt-5.6-sol",
    "writer": "openai/gpt-5.6-sol",
    "analysis_engineer": "openai/gpt-5.6-sol"
  }
}